Roof replacement cost is the first question most homeowners research before they call a contractor, and the internet makes it harder to answer clearly than it should be. National average figures are often misleading because roofing costs vary significantly by market. This page focuses on what replacement actually costs in Kentucky and Ohio, where Craftsmen Contractors works, based on real projects we’ve completed across Lexington, Cincinnati, and our broader service area.
45+ Years | Licensed & Insured | 500+ Happy Customers
Three-tab asphalt shingles are the budget option and are becoming less common in new installations as the price gap between three-tab and architectural products has narrowed. For a typical Kentucky or Ohio single-story home, three-tab replacement runs $7,500 to $12,000 including tear-off and permit.
Architectural shingles are the standard recommendation for most Craftsmen Contractors projects in Kentucky and Ohio. They carry 30-year warranties, perform better in the region’s storm season, and look significantly better than three-tab. Replacement on a typical home runs $9,000 to $16,000.
Standing seam and metal shingle systems have grown in popularity across our service area as homeowners look for longer-term solutions. Metal roofing on a typical Kentucky or Ohio home runs $14,000 to $25,000 depending on the system and profile. The lifespan advantage, typically 40 to 60 years versus 25 to 35 for architectural shingles, changes the long-term cost calculation for homeowners who plan to stay in their home.
Most Lexington homeowners can expect to pay between $5.50 and $11 per square foot, depending on roofing materials, roof pitch, and project complexity. This estimate includes both materials and labor, with most local contractors pricing jobs between $450 and $1,000 per square (100 sq ft).
Here’s how those figures typically play out based on common home sizes in Central Kentucky:
Home Size
Low-End Cost
High-End Cost
Per Sq Ft
1,000 Sq Ft
$5,500
$11,000
$5.50-11
1,500 Sq Ft
$8,250
$16,500
$5.50-11
2,000 Sq Ft
$11,000
$22,000
$5.50-11
Every new roof is an investment in two essentials—experienced craftsmanship and durable, weather-rated materials. With Kentucky’s mix of humidity, heavy rain, and spring hail, that balance determines how long your roof truly lasts.
A precise installation following certified manufacturer standards ensures that each shingle, flashing, and seal performs under pressure, protecting your home season after season. When labor and materials work together in balance, the result is a roof designed to handle Central Kentucky’s climate for decades.
Material
3-Tab Asphalt Shingles
Cost Range $3–6/Sq Ft
Lifespan 15–25 Years
Best For Budget-conscious projects
Architectural Shingles
Cost Range $5.50–8.50/Sq Ft
Lifespan 30–50 Years
Best For Long-term durability and value
Metal Roofing
Cost Range $8–11/Sq Ft
Lifespan 40–70 Years
Best For High-wind and hail protection
Cedar or Wood Shakes
Cost Range $8–12/Sq Ft
Lifespan 30–40 Years
Best For Rustic or custom designs
Slate or Synthetic Slate
Cost Range $10–20/Sq Ft
Lifespan 75–100 Years
Best For Historic or high-end homes
3-Tab Asphalt Shingles
Architectural Shingles
Metal Roofing
Cedar or Wood Shakes
Slate or Synthetic Slate
Cost Range
$3–6/Sq Ft
$5.50–8.50/Sq Ft
$8–11/Sq Ft
$8–12/Sq Ft
$10–20/Sq Ft
Lifespan
15–25 Years
30–50 Years
40–70 Years
30–40 Years
75–100 Years
Best For
Budget-conscious projects
Long-term durability and value
High-wind and hail protection
Rustic or custom designs
Historic or high-end homes
When it comes to protecting your home, local expertise matters. Craftsmen Roofing and Exteriors is known across Central Kentucky for dependable service, transparent pricing, and roofs built to last.
We bring professional craftsmanship and regional knowledge to every project—from storm-damaged homes in Tates Creek to full roof replacements in Richmond or Georgetown. Every roof installation is supervised by trained field managers who ensure materials and workmanship meet manufacturer and warranty standards.
As a locally owned and operated company, Craftsmen Roofing and Exteriors stands behind every project with a 5-year transferable craftsmanship warranty and lifetime roof guarantee.
That’s why Lexington homeowners continue to choose us because craftsmanship, care, and honesty never go out of style.
Roof replacement costs in the Cincinnati area typically run 10 to 20 percent higher than central Kentucky markets like Lexington. This reflects labor market differences rather than material costs. Homes in the
Cincinnati metro area also tend to have more complex roof geometry on average due to the housing stock, which adds labor time.
Asphalt shingle replacement on a typical Kentucky home runs $7,500 to $14,000 including permit, tear-off, and standard underlayment. Architectural shingles on the same home cost $9,000 to $16,000. Metal roofing runs $14,000 to $25,000. Factors like roof size, pitch, and decking condition affect the final number. Craftsmen Contractors provides free written estimates.
Roof replacement in the Cincinnati area runs slightly higher than central Kentucky. Asphalt shingle replacement on a typical Cincinnati home runs $9,000 to $17,000. Architectural shingles run $11,000 to $19,000. Craftsmen Contractors provides free on-site estimates for Cincinnati area homes with no obligation.
The main variables are roof size in squares, pitch steepness, how many layers of existing material need to be removed, whether any decking needs replacement, the material tier chosen, and the number of penetrations and valleys on the roof. Steeper pitches and two-layer tear-offs add to the final cost.
Most single-story homes in our Kentucky and Ohio service area are between 20 and 35 squares of roof surface. A 2,000 sq ft single-story home with a standard 5:12 pitch typically runs around 22 to 26 squares depending on overhang and geometry. Craftsmen Contractors measures your roof accurately during the free estimate visit.
Roof size, slope, access difficulty, and chosen materials all affect project pricing. Homes requiring tear-offs, structural repairs, or enhanced ventilation often need additional labor hours, impacting the final estimate and overall installation cost.
Premium shingles, metal panels, and synthetic systems cost more initially but provide superior durability, longer warranties, and lower maintenance needs. They perform better against Kentucky’s humidity, hail, and temperature shifts, offering long-term savings and enhanced home protection.
When storm or hail damage is confirmed, most homeowner insurance policies help cover repair or replacement costs. A professional inspection and claim assistance streamline approval, ensuring accurate documentation and faster project completion within coverage terms.
Proper ventilation may slightly raise initial costs but prevents trapped moisture, ice dams, and heat buildup. It protects insulation, shingles, and decking from premature failure while maintaining manufacturer warranty coverage and long-term roofing efficiency.
Flexible financing programs with $0 down, quick approval, and adjustable monthly terms allow homeowners to begin projects without delay. Financing can also be combined with insurance coverage to simplify budgeting and maximize overall project value.
Need a new roof or repair? Get a free, no-obligation quote from trusted roofing professionals. Our team will inspect your roof, discuss your options, and give you a fair estimate that fits your budget. Protect your home with quality materials and expert service—request your quote today!
